Kitty Kick Stix 11" Original Catnip Kicker Toy (Set of 2), Handmade in USA by Cat Lovers, Interactive Natural Cat & Kitten Toy, Packed with 100% Potent Catnip for All Breeds

$15.49

Compare at 3 stores

Wool Cat Toys - Felt Cat Toy Balls Assortments for Small Pet Fetch and Play - Eco Friendly Quiet Wool Ball Cat Toy for Cats and Kittens - Choose Your Colors (Variety Pack)

$9.99

Compare at 3 stores

Natural Cat Toy Eco-Kitty Catcher Offers Loads of Interactive Fun for Both Owner and cat-Made of Natural Wool and Hemp Twine-Cat Toy Guarantee from Honest Pet Products

$15.19

Compare at 3 stores

Barn Yarn Hand Knit Wool Cat Toy, stuffed with Organic Catnip (3 pack)

$11.98

Compare at 11 stores

Yeowww! Catnip Toy, Yellow Banana

$8.23

Compare at 38 stores

SmartyKat Instincts 3-Pack Catnip Caravan Mice Plush Cat Toys, Contains Catnip & Silvervine - Multicolor, 3-Pack

$5.99

Compare at 13 stores

Kitty Kick Stix 15" Original Catnip Kicker Toy (Set of 2), Handmade in USA by Cat Lovers, Interactive Natural Cat & Kitten Toy, Packed with 100% Potent Catnip for All Breeds (Cat Selfie)

$19.79

Compare at 4 stores

Catstages Loaf Kicker Catnip Toy and Dental Toy for Cats Bread Themed Funny Catnip Stuffed Kicker Toy, Tan

$5.99

Compare at 9 stores

Yeowww My Cats Balls, 3 Balls per Pack

$12.89

Compare at 39 stores

Natural Cat Toy Eco-Kitty Catcher Offers Loads of Interactive Fun for Both Owner and cat-Made of Natural Wool and Hemp Twine-Cat Toy Guarantee from Honest Pet Products

$15.19

Compare at 3 stores

Cat Toys Interactive with Motion Activated & Chirping, Rolling Super Fast on Carpet Happy Party Game with Kittens - Red

$19.99

Compare at 36 stores

Interactive Cat Ball Toy, Intelligent Cat Toys with LED Lights, Automatic Moving Rolling Ball for Indoor Cats, Cat Automatic Toy

$9.99

Compare at 2 stores

Furhaven 3-Pack Catnip Plush Cat Kicker Toy - Catnip Bags Included - Durable & Washable - Space Print, Set of 3

$15.99

Compare at 6 stores

Blue Q Existential Kitty Catnip Cat Toy. Premium Organic Catnip Grown in The USA, 100% Cotton Pouches, Kitty Graphics Sure to Delight Every Cat-Keeper.

$9.99

Compare at 25 stores

Yeowww! Catnip Toy, Rainbow

$9.69

Compare at 36 stores

SmartyKat Instincts 3-Pack HappyNip Tricky Tea Bags Cat Toys, Contains Catnip & Silvervine - Multicolor, 3-Pack

$5.24

Compare at 11 stores

Jackson Galaxy Gotcha! Cat Wand Toy - Interactive Cat Toy, Feather Wand

$15.99

Compare at 3 stores

Catstages Crunchy Pickle Kicker Dental Catnip Cat Toy

$5.59

Compare at 41 stores

SmartyKat Hot Pursuit Electronic Concealed Motion Cat Toy, Battery Powered - Blue, One Size

$14.72

Compare at 46 stores

Ethical Pets 52084 Wool Mouse Willie Catnip Toys

$6

Compare at 36 stores